Hey! My name is Ann Ittoop and I am a South Indian/American South food blogger.

Recent Posts

    Sorry, no posts matched your criteria.

Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta

Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta

I like to think about the recipes my mom taught me as a kid and credit her with a lot of what I’ve learned. I need to give some credit to my dad, too, though. Father’s aren’t always seen in the home kitchen, especially in our culture, but there are plenty of men who cook. That’s why I am sharing this Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta with you.

My father came to this country with the American dream in his pocket. He came to build a life full of opportunity, not just for himself, but more for his future family. Dad’s first job was at Pizza Hut as a district manager. Which is funny because he once told me when he was younger, he thought pizza was some sort of dessert! Our home was full of Pizza Hut-everything. We had the cups, plates, t-shirts – but, the thing we kept over the years were four little brown clay baking dishes. I cherished just the sight of these little dishes coming out of our cabinets because it meant that dad was going to make us all his famous baked spaghetti.

Dad’s recipe wasn’t anything out of the ordinary. Boxed spaghetti noodles, jarred tomato sauce, ground beef, and cheese. But, he treated the process as if he was making magic. He always quietly told us that a little sprinkle of sugar was the secret ingredient in his cauldron of sauce. Getting to hold on to these four dishes in my own kitchen today? Well, it is special. Not just so I can bake pasta, but so that I can relive those tender moments of happiness and joy.

About this recipe

The recipe below is a modern ode to my dad’s original recipe. This Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta is full of flavor and is so easy to make. The way the mushrooms are cooked are meant to mimic the ground beef we’d typically use in the recipe – trust me, even mushroom haters can’t hate this! I hope you enjoy making this recipe! As always, if you have any questions about my recipes, cooking tips, or anything reach out to me on Instagram @thefamiliarkitchen and please tag me if you decide to make this!

Be sure to check out my other pasta dishes like my Harissa Lime Pasta and Everything Bagel Cheese Pasta.

Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne PastaCheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta

Cheesy Baked Mushroom Penne Pasta

Prep Time10 mins
Cook Time35 mins
Total Time45 mins
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: Fusion, Italian
Keyword: dinner, pasta, vegetarian
Servings: 6 people
Author: The Familiar Kitchen


  • Penne Pasta, 16 oz box, cooked
  • Parmesan Cheese, 1 cup, grated
  • Mozzarella Slices, as needed
  • Parsley, finely chopped

Mushroom "Meat"

  • Olive Oil, 2 tbsp
  • Portobello Mushrooms, 6, large, finely diced
  • Hickory Liquid Smoke (by Colgin), 1/2 tsp
  • Salt, 1/2 tsp

Pasta Sauce

  • Olive Oil, 2 tbsp
  • Onion, 1, diced
  • Bell Pepper (any color), 1, diced
  • Jalapeno Pepper, 2, diced
  • Garlic Cloves, 6, minced
  • Diced Tomatoes, 2 cups (canned is fine)
  • Italian Seasoning Blend, 2 tbsp
  • Brown Sugar, 1 tbsp


Make the meat.

  • In a skillet on high heat, add the olive oil. Once the oil is hot, add in the finely diced portobello mushrooms. Cook for about 6-8 minutes or until the mushrooms water content cooks out and they become slightly crisp. Add in the liquid smoke and the salt then mix together. Set aside.

Cook the pasta. 

  • Bring a pot of water to a rumbling boil and add about 2 tbsp of salt to the water. Once the water comes to a rumbling boil, cook the pasta according to the box instructions. I typically cook for about 7-8 minutes to get firm pasta. Immediately drain the pasta under cool water, but be sure to reserve a 1/2 cup of the pasta cooking water.

Make the tomato sauce.

  • In the same skillet on medium high heat, add the olive oil. Once the oil is hot, add the onions, bell peppers, jalapenos, and garlic cloves. Saute until lightly golden and soft. Now add in the diced tomatoes and mix everything together. Finally, mix in the Italian seasoning and brown sugar. Transfer the chunky sauce to a mixing bowl and use an immersion blender to puree the sauce. *Alternatively, wait until the chunky sauce has cooled down then use a blender to puree the sauce. 

Mix it all together and bake.

  • Preheat the oven to 400 degrees. Now add the cooked pasta, pasta water, mushroom meat, tomato sauce, and parmesan to your pot. Toss everything together until evenly mixed. Add the pasta to a baking dish and top with the mozzarella slices and parsley. Bake just until the cheese is melted and bubbly. Done!

Hey! My name is Ann Ittoop and I am a South Indian/American South food blogger. Growing up as a second-generation Indian-American, I got the chance to experience the best of both food worlds, oftentimes on one plate! On one hand I had Kerala staples like appam and chicken curry. On the other I had chicken and waffles. If there’s one thing that has helped me understand my identity and express both ends of my cultural upbringing, it’s most definitely food. I have a firm belief there is literally magic in the cooking process. That’s why most nights you’ll find me in the kitchen. I’m there always testing and creating new recipes that stem from my wild imagination. And I’m there searching for the familiar memories of my childhood. I started The Familiar Kitchen to not only help myself find this magic, but for those seeking a way to find their own magic. Join me on my adventures through cooking classic Kerala-inspired dishes, some of my Southern favorites, and all the recipes in between.

Post a Comment